Japanese Hostesses and Hosts

This will probably be my most popular blog post, and not for the right reasons. But I think I can bring my powers of dispassionate observation to bear on the Japanese sex-work industry without sounding too creepy.

While in Fukuoka I walked through the red light district a few times. It was as clean and quiet as anywhere else, but at night, male and female staff stood outside clubs to lure passersby. The men dressed in suits, the women in white gothic lolita outfits. They all left me alone, avoiding mutual assured embarrassment. But their trade magazines were everywhere, and I picked one up.
IMG_4024

Inside was page after page of impossibly kawaii women. The term encompasses cute but means far more: it’s intimately wrapped up with concepts of female sexuality as docile and non-threatening, which is pretty clear from the imagery:

IMG_4033

IMG_4034

IMG_4038

Wikipedia suggests the trend evokes “the helplessness and innocence of young girls”. This is part of a long-standing odalisque tradition in the west – but patriarchy is global.

These are young girls you can drink with from 8pm to close, for a sizeable sum of money (4,800 Yen = $51 US, plus expensive drinks), although my understanding is, despite the pornographic pose, no sex is involved:

IMG_4039

IMG_4040

More telling were the trade ads towards the middle of the magazine:

IMG_4046

IMG_4045

IMG_4044

There’s no attempt to hide the lengths these women go to construct their image. 50,000 Yen is not a cheap entry fee to an industry – although much cheaper than a degree, I suppose.

Girls who are boys who like boys to be girls

So far, so prurient. And then, right at the centre staple, this:

IMG_4050

The construction of Asian women as sex objects isn’t news. As someone pointed out, try a google image search of Asian men, then Asian women and see the difference. However, while female sexuality is one of Asia’s biggest exports, male sexuality is strictly for domestic consumption. Which I find fascinating. I mean, look at these guys:

IMG_4054

IMG_4052

IMG_4055

IMG_4059

IMG_4053
Who knew Frodo had a second career as a Fukuoka bar host?

The men are childlike and non-threatening as well. Hardman archetypes are common in Japan (for plenty of historical and cultural reasons I won’t get into). But not to party with: in the bar, the guys are smooth-faced, waterfall-haired and kitten-like.

IMG_4060

IMG_4065

IMG_4066

IMG_4064
This one is a centerfold, just like the women’s.

At least there’s an appearance of equality to the sex- and affect-work. Men and women not only have equal space in the magazine, they aspire to very similar looks. There are hints of androgyny amidst the ultra-femininity and masculinity. There are also exceptions. Buried in the club ads is one for these women:

IMG_4042

They’re not conforming to regular body standards. And neither are these guys:

IMG_4049

IMG_4048
Would you really want to drink champagne with him? Apparently it’s a selling point.

This is why I picked up the magazine: I was expecting all sexy-kawaii, and instead there were exceptions which, if they didn’t contradict that image, at least broadened it.

If you’ve made it this far, I highly recommend watching Great Happiness Space: Tales of an Osaka Love Thief, which strips bare the illusions of hosting and shows it for the incredibly hard and sad work it actually is. Also Japan: A Story of Love and Hate, for the sheer grind of emotional labour that host-work entails:
Like to work? (Love & Hate)

Customer service (Love & Hate)

Finally, I’m not going all pomo and celebrating the hosts as subverting dominant sexual narratives, even the differently-shaped ones. As the documentary makes clear, dominant notions of gendered sexuality are very much in play, with tragic consequences for some men and women. Beyond the titillation factor, it’s still a job, and most jobs suck. Last word to the hostess and her husband:

It's capitalism (Love & Hate)

No time for happiness (Love & Hate)

Advertisements

One thought on “Japanese Hostesses and Hosts

  1. Pingback: The Relentless Metropolis – Tokyo, Friday May 24 | The Rootless Metropolitan

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s